15 de abril de 1931, 3:47 pm Restaurante Nuova Villa Tammaro, Coney Island.
Joe “The Boss” Masseria, the most powerful Mafia boss in New York, was having a good day. He had just won $400 playing cards with Lucky Luciano. Now he was ordering dessert. Apple pie, his favorite. The waiter brought the pie, steaming hot, fresh from the oven. Masseria picked up his fork, smiled, and took the first bite.
That’s when Lucky Luciano got up from the table.
—Excuse me, boss. I need to use the restroom.
Masseria waved goodbye without looking up, still chewing that first bite of cake, still thinking about the $400 in his pocket. Lucky walked to the back of the restaurant, pushed open the bathroom door, and closed it behind him.
For exactly 7 seconds, the restaurant was silent. Only the sound of Masseria’s fork scraping against the plate.
Then the front door opened. Four men entered: suits, hats down, hands in their pockets. Masseria looked up from his cake. He had just enough time to recognize one of them—Vito Genovese—before they drew their weapons.
What happened in the next 30 seconds would end the Castellammare War, kill New York’s most powerful boss, and create the perfect alibi for Lucky Luciano. Because when the shooting started, Lucky was in the bathroom washing his hands, not hearing a thing. Or so he would tell the police.
To understand why Lucky Luciano killed his own boss, you need to understand the war that was tearing New York apart in 1931: the Castellammare War. Two years of bloodshed. Old world versus new world. Tradition versus progress.
On one side, Joe “the Boss” Masseria. Neapolitan. Old school. He had been the most powerful Mafia boss in New York for a decade. His rule was simple: Italians only. Sicilians and Neapolitans could work together, but everyone else—Jews, Irish, anyone—was the enemy.
On the other side was Salvatore Maranzano. Sicilian, even more old-school. He had studied to be a priest, spoke perfect Latin, and saw himself as a Caesar building a Roman Empire. Maranzano wanted to be the *capo di tutti capi* (boss of all bosses), a man ruling everything.
Both men were dinosaurs. Both refused to evolve, and both were bleeding the organization dry.
Lucky Luciano was caught in the middle. He was Masseria’s top earner, his most trusted soldier, the man Masseria called “my son.” But Lucky was different from both bosses. He was 33, born in Sicily, but raised on Manhattan’s Lower East Side. He had grown up with Meyer Lansky, a Jew; with Bugsy Siegel, another Jew; with Frank Costello, an Italian who believed in working with anyone who could make money.
Lucky had a vision: organized crime as a business, not a blood feud; a Commission where bosses voted on decisions instead of shooting each other. Jews, Italians, Irish… if you were smart and could make money, you were in. It was brilliant. It was modern. It was everything the old guard hated.
And that’s why Lucky knew that if the mafia was going to survive, both Masseria and Maranzano had to die, starting with their own boss.
March 1931. The War of Castellammare had lasted two years. Sixty men dead, millions lost, territory divided and fought over like a medieval kingdom. Lucky sat in his apartment with Meyer Lansky and Bugsy Siegel. They had been counting the bodies, tallying the losses.
“This has to stop,” Meyer said. “We’re bleeding money, losing soldiers. The police are watching everything we do.”
“They’re both too stubborn to make peace,” Bugsy added. “Masseria won’t negotiate. Maranzano won’t compromise. They’d rather burn everything down than share power.”
Lucky was silent, thinking, calculating.
“What if,” Lucky said slowly, “we finish it ourselves?”
Meyer and Bugsy looked at him.
—Do you mean…?
—I mean, we get rid of Masseria, make it look like Maranzano won the war, then get rid of Maranzano and build something new. Something that actually works.
Meyer leaned back.
—You’re talking about killing your own boss.
—I’m talking about ending a war that is killing us all.
Bugsy smiled.
—I’m in.
Meyer nodded.
-When?
“Soon,” Lucky said. “I’ll organize it.”
What Lucky didn’t tell them, what he couldn’t tell them, was that this wasn’t just strategy. This was personal. Masseria had been good to Lucky, trusted him, promoted him, called him son; and Lucky was about to betray that trust completely. But Lucky had learned something growing up on the streets: loyalty is important, but survival is everything. And Joe Masseria was going to get them all killed.
Planning the perfect murder requires time, patience, and attention to detail. Lucky spent three weeks preparing.
First, the location. It had to be a place where Masseria felt safe, a place where he wouldn’t suspect a trap. Lucky chose Nuova Villa Tammaro, a small Italian restaurant in Coney Island that Masseria loved. The owner, Gerardo Scarpato, was a friend of Masseria’s—or so Masseria thought. Lucky met with Scarpato privately and offered him $500.
—On April 15th, I’m bringing Mr. Masseria over for lunch. Around 3:00 pm, four men will come in. When they do, you disappear. You don’t see anything. You don’t hear anything. Understood?
Scarpato took the money.
Second, the shooters. Lucky needed men he could trust, men who wouldn’t hesitate. He chose four: Vito Genovese, Albert Anastasia, Joe Adonis, and Bugsy Siegel. Each had killed before. Each wanted Masseria dead.
“Here’s how it works,” Lucky told them. “I’ll call you when we’re finishing lunch. When you come in, I’ll be in the bathroom. Make it quick. Six shots, then leave. Don’t run. Walk out like nothing happened.”
Third, the alibi. This was the most important part. Lucky couldn’t be near Masseria when the shooting happened. He needed to be visible, somewhere the police couldn’t dispute. The bathroom was perfect. One entrance, one exit, a window that closed from the inside. When the shooting happened, Lucky would be washing his hands. He couldn’t have seen anything. He couldn’t have been involved.
Fourth, the invitation. It couldn’t seem suspicious. It had to be natural, casual.
On the morning of April 15, Lucky called Masseria.
—Chief, do you have time for lunch today? I have some thoughts on Maranzano’s situation. I thought we could talk.
Masseria was always interested in talking about Maranzano: his enemy, his obsession.
-Where?
—New Villa Tammaro. Your favorite place. At 1:00.
—See you there, boss.
Lucky hung up. He looked at Vito Genovese, who was sitting in his apartment.
“It’s underway,” Lucky said. “3:00. Don’t be late.”
April 15, 1931. 1:00 pm. Lucky Luciano arrived at Nuova Villa Tammaro 15 minutes early. He checked the design. He made sure the bathroom door worked smoothly. He made sure Scarpato understood the plan.
1:15 pm Joe Masseria arrived. Big smile, expensive suit, bodyguards waiting outside. Masseria had told them to stay in the car. This was a private lunch with Lucky, his most trusted soldier. There was no need for protection.
They sat at a corner table and ordered food. Masseria ordered wine. They talked about business, the war, and what to do next.
2:30 pm The food arrived. Beef, pasta, fresh bread. They ate slowly. Masseria was relaxed, happy. He liked these lunches with Lucky; he liked having someone intelligent to talk to.
3:15 p.m.
—Do you want to play cards? —Masseria asked.
Lucky smiled.
—Sure, boss.
They played for 30 minutes. Masseria won $400. Lucky let him win. He kept him happy. He kept him relaxed.
3:45 p.m.
“I’m going to order dessert,” Masseria said. “The best apple pie in Brooklyn.”
—Sounds good, boss.
The waiter brought the cake. Still warm, steaming hot.
3:47 pm Masseria took the first bite. That’s when Lucky stood up.
—Excuse me, boss. I need to use the restroom.
Masseria waved goodbye.
—Go ahead. I’ll save you some cake.
Lucky walked to the back of the restaurant. Each step was measured, calm, natural. He pushed open the bathroom door, closed it behind him, turned on the tap, let the water run, and waited.
3:49 pm The front door opened. Four men entered. Vito Genovese, Albert Anastasia, Joe Adonis, Bugsy Siegel. Gerardo Scarpato, the restaurant owner, saw them and disappeared into the kitchen as he had been told.
Masseria looked up from his cake and saw the men. Recognition flashed across his face. He reached for the gun at his waist. Too slow.
3:50 pm The first shot. Then five more in quick succession. Masseria’s body jerked with each impact. The fork fell from his hand. The pie slid off the table. Blood spread across the white tablecloth. Six bullets: four in the back, two in the head. Joe “The Chief” Masseria was dead before he hit the floor.
The four men turned around and walked away. No running, no panicking; just four men leaving a restaurant on a Wednesday afternoon. Total time elapsed: 45 seconds.
3:52 pm Lucky Luciano turned off the tap, dried his hands carefully, left the bathroom, and saw his boss slumped over the table, blood everywhere, the apple pie on the floor. Lucky’s face showed perfect shock, perfect horror.
He walked over to the phone and dialed the operator.
—Yes, I need the police. There’s been a shooting. Nuova Villa Tammaro Restaurant, Coney Island. I think… I think my boss is dead.
Her voice trembled. Convincing. Perfect.
4:05 pm The police arrived. Detectives, uniformed officers, photographers. Joe Masseria’s body was still slumped on the table. The apple pie was still on the floor. Six shell casings were scattered around the dining room.
Detective Michael Fiaschetti approached Lucky Luciano, who was sitting at the bar looking shocked.
—Mr. Luciano, were you here when this happened?
—Yes, sir. Joe, Mr. Masseria, is my boss. We were having lunch.
—Where were you when the shooting happened?
Lucky pointed to the bathroom.
—I was washing my hands. I heard loud noises. I thought it was a car backfiring outside. Then I went outside and… and found him like this.
Detective Fiaschetti walked to the bathroom, checked the window: locked from the inside. He checked other exits. None. The only way out was through the dining room.
—Didn’t you see the shooters?
—No, sir.
—He heard six shots and thought it was a car.
The door was closed. The water was running. I didn’t know what was happening until it was over.
Fiaschetti stared at Lucky. 28 years old. Calm. Too calm for someone who had just witnessed his boss’s murder.
Did Mr. Masseria have any enemies?
Lucky almost laughed.
“The boss had many enemies, detective. There’s a war going on. You know that.”
—Any idea who might have done this?
—No idea. It could be anyone.
Fiaschetti wanted to arrest him. Every instinct told him Lucky was involved, but there was no evidence, no witnesses, no weapon. Just a man who went to the bathroom at exactly the wrong time… or exactly the right time.
“You are free to leave, Mr. Luciano, but do not leave the city.”
-Yes sir.
Lucky Luciano left Nuova Villa Tammaro at 4:45 pm on April 15, 1931.
By 5:00 pm, every Mafia boss in New York knew that Joe Masseria was dead. The Castellammare War was over. Salvatore Maranzano had won.
By 6:00 pm, Lucky was meeting with Maranzano, shaking hands, smiling.
—Congratulations, boss. You won.
Maranzano smiled back, having no idea that in five months, Lucky would kill him too.
The murder of Joe Masseria became legendary. Not because of the violence—mafia killings happened all the time—but because of its perfection. The alibi was unbreakable. Lucky Luciano was in the bathroom. The door was closed. The water was running. He couldn’t have seen anything. He couldn’t have been involved.
The police knew he did it. Every cop in New York knew it, but knowing and proving are different things. No witnesses came forward. The restaurant owner saw nothing. The four shooters vanished into the city. The gun was never found.
Detective Fiaschetti would later say: “We knew Lucky Luciano ordered that hit. We knew he planned every detail, but we couldn’t prove a damn thing. It was the perfect crime.”
And he was right. Lucky had learned something that day, something that would define the rest of his career: the best alibi isn’t being somewhere else. It’s being right there, but making everyone believe you weren’t involved.
Over the years, the story grew. People added details. They said Lucky was playing cards when the shooting happened. They said he stormed out whistling. They said he finished Masseria’s apple pie before calling the police. None of it was true. But it didn’t matter. The legend was better than the truth.
What was true? Lucky Luciano killed his own boss, used trust as a weapon, created the perfect alibi, and walked away unscathed. Five months later, he would kill Maranzano in the same way: with planning, precision, and flawless execution. And from those two murders, Lucky built the Commission, the modern Mafia, a system that lasted for decades.
All because he understood one thing: sometimes, the most loyal thing you can do is betray the people who hold everyone else back.
Joe Masseria died eating apple pie. He never saw it coming. He never suspected his most trusted soldier. And Lucky Luciano… he went to the bathroom, washed his hands, and changed organized crime forever.
If this story of betrayal, strategy, and the perfect alibi moved you, hit that subscribe button. We’re telling the stories of Lucky Luciano that history forgot. The heists that made him legendary. The decisions that made him untouchable. The moments that changed the Mafia forever.
Leave a like if you thought Lucky’s bathroom alibi was brilliant. And in the comments, would you have suspected Lucky if you were the detective? Turn on notifications because next time we’ll tell the story of how Lucky killed Salvatore Maranzano with four fake police officers and created the Commission. Remember, the perfect crime isn’t getting away with murder. It’s making everyone believe you weren’t even there.
